Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dionne Dumitru's avatar

How humans progressed from the flat, egalitarian model of society to the hierarchical one we know is intriguing. If the societal changes occurred in times of crisis, there’s brain chemistry to consider as well: flight or fight bypasses the prefrontal cortex, making it impossible to think your way out while you’re gripped by fear. I also wonder if this (the perceived need for strength in the face of crisis) reinforced the importance of larger group sizes, since societies larger than the bands you talk about can’t be held together as easily with personal relationships, and the larger the society the better it can defend itself.

Expand full comment
Ed P's avatar

Fascinating perspective! Thank you

Conjured for me opening scenes of Arthur C Clarke’s 2001: A Space Odyssey, where different from the movie, the monolith ‘teaches’ an ape to throw rocks as a weapon/tool in an epic inflection point in the evolution of intelligence. It never sat right with me the film adaption where instead, the apes learn to use bones as bludgeoning weapons. Now I know better why. It sure does make sense that use of throwing weapons is the particular advance that is the key turning point where intelligence bests bodily strength as human’s most critical security asset.

In the original Odyssey, it is Odysseus’s cunning and resourcefulness that wins the day over and over. Maybe Homer was trying to remind the Greeks how dumb/disastrous it is to embrace Chimpy instincts and hide behind ‘strong men’ when threatened.

When you can no longer tell who is most dangerous by sizing them up from a distance, it sure changes the game.

Just picked up Corruptible, btw, looking forward to it!

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts