Jimmy Carter's Hidden Legacy
Carter's post-presidency has been transformative. And while he's well-known for his contributions to democracy, he deserves immense credit for his incredible successes with global public health.
Thank you for reading The Garden of Forking Paths. This newsletter is entirely supported by reader support. If you enjoy reading these articles, please consider clicking the button below to upgrade to a paid subscription. Thank you for reading—and your support.
Last week, the Carter family announced that former U.S. president Jimmy Carter is receiving hospice care as he nears the end of his life. The 39th president of the United States has seen immense change in his lifetime, as he was born in 1924, five years before the beginning of the Great Depression. Nearly a century later, Carter has had, by every conceivable metric, a life well lived.
It now sadly seems inevitable that the obituaries are not far away. Hopefully, they will offer a corrective to a skewed narrative of Carter as a failure. He has been unfairly maligned for decades, his achievements and foresight overshadowed by his inability to get re-elected and by foreign policy debacles that have seemingly undercut everything else he achieved.
But achieve much he did.
Carter deregulated airlines, bringing affordble air travel to the masses; he appointed 57 ethnic minority judges to the bench, along with 41 female judges—more than all of his predecessors combined; he advocated for environmental policies that were decades before their time; and in an era in which the United States was notorious for propping up murderous regimes across the globe so long as they were our allies, he put human rights center stage in American foreign policy debates. Carter was a consequential president.
But unlike most presidents, Carter did more for humanity after leaving the White House. The Carter Center, the NGO that he founded in 1982, has been a crucial force for good, known primarily for its work on successfully promoting democracy and providing high-quality election monitoring across the globe. It deserves that reputation. (A decade ago, I served as the political adviser for The Carter Center’s election observation mission to Madagascar. It is a rare bright spot of impartial global election oversight, ruthlessly committed to democracy, divorced from the biases of geopolitics).
However, few people know about some of Carter’s most astonishing post-presidency achievements in the field of public health. These are his hidden legacies, the gifts he’s bestowed on humanity that will be reducing suffering for millions of people, long after he’s gone. Carter deserves immense credit for them.
Guinea worm and river blindness
In the mid-1980s, nearly four million people were infected by Guinea Worm each year. Caused by the parasitic roundworm Dracunculus medinensis, it’s certainly a disease you wouldn’t want to experience. The infections come from stagnant water, in which the worms lay their larvae, but the worms mature inside the human body. Over the course of a year, an infected person eventually plays host to a worm that grows to become one meter (3.3 feet) long. Yikes.
Once full grown, the worm creates a lesion on the skin and then escapes from the body, usually producing agonizing pain in the process. Most of the time, these worms exit through the legs or the feet, and you can imagine it’s not a pleasant experience to have a three foot-long worm crawling out of you. Fully removing the worm can take days or weeks. It’s extremely painful, and often leads to secondary infections. Most people who get sick are debilitated for weeks or months, and some develop permanently disabling joint pain. This is one nasty parasite.
Jimmy Carter decided to do something about it.
There was no glory in it. This wasn’t like cutting a ribbon or raising funds for a high-profile cause. In the United States and other rich countries, few people had ever heard of guinea worm, so Carter wasn’t exactly about to generate front page publicity for taking the parasite on, but he nonetheless decided to make it a core of his post-presidency public health agenda. And it’s hard to overstate just how successful he’s been. Take a look at this chart (from NPR), showing the estimated number of cases in 1986 versus today, due to the Carter Center’s investments to eradicate the disease.
Before Carter got involved, Guinea Worm was prevalent in 21 countries, infecting at least 3.5 million people per year. Today, that figure is down to just 13 cases per year. It’s a reduction of 99.99% in just a few decades, making it one of the most successful public health interventions in history. Experts estimate that, without the efforts of the Carter Center, roughly 80 million more people would have been infected by Guinea Worm. Instead, they were saved from excruciating pain and crippling disease by a former president who gave a damn about a disease that nobody else seemed to care about.
The Garden of Forking Paths is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Similarly, the Carter Center has done tremendous work at tackling onchocerciasis, or river blindness. That disease comes from black fly bites, and it’s prevalent in 31 countries, mostly in sub-Saharan Africa. Again, it’s a largely neglected disease, despite the fact that just shy of 20 million people are currently infected, with about a million of them having lost their vision due to the infection. Here’s the regional distribution of where the disease persists, from Our World in Data.
The Carter Center has provided hundreds of millions of rounds of treatment for river blindness, drastically alleviating avoidable suffering. It doesn’t generate headlines, nor is it usually mentioned as a core part of Carter’s reputation in American political discourse, but had Jimmy Carter not decided to devote his efforts to these programs, millions more people would have been needlessly blinded by a devastating parasite.
The post-presidency reveals a president’s true character
There are good presidents and bad ones, but it’s often difficult to disentangle how much of a president’s legacy is down to character, how much is down to skill, and how much is down to luck. After all, it’s much easier to get things done if Congress is from the same party, and it’s much better to preside over a global period of immense peace and economic growth (as Bill Clinton did) than to govern during a time of upheaval or war. Presidents affect outcomes, but they don’t control them, and to a certain extent, they are beholden to the whims of history. Carter was no exception.
That’s why post-presidency legacies are so fascinating, because they reveal true character that is dissociated from the vicious political battles in Washington and the flukes of history.
Herbert Hoover’s political choices in the White House helped spark the Great Depression. But after his presidency, he helped feed German children following World War II and successfully oversaw substantial US government reforms that were widely regarded as a monumental achievement. Rutherford B. Hayes, one of the most forgotten presidents, devoted his post-presidency to educational justice. And Bill Clinton has produced tremendous success through the Clinton Foundation and Clinton Global Initiative, most notably after the devastating 2010 Haiti earthquake.
Admittedly, post-presidencies have gotten much longer in recent decades, given modern presidents more of a shot at making an impact. George Washington died just two years after leaving the presidency, coming down with a fatal illness while riding a horse around his farm in 1799. Carter, by contrast, has been a former president for more than four decades.
This is an arena in which Donald Trump’s character has been revealed in a particularly harsh light. What has Trump devoted himself to doing since leaving the White House? Cashing in on lucrative business deals, golfing, and unhinged ranting on social media. About par for the course, I suppose.
Can anyone imagine Trump championing a cause like trying to eradicate a neglected disease like Guinea Worm? (Yes, that is indeed a rhetorical question).
The world doesn’t have much longer with Jimmy Carter, but Jimmy Carter’s presence will be felt around the world long after he passes away. When he dies, consider his hidden legacies, because he has saved millions upon millions of people from excruciating pain, debilitating disease, and blindness. That, surely, is a legacy we can all agree is worth celebrating.
Thank you for reading. If you’ve enjoyed my writing or learned something new from it, please consider upgrading to a paid subscription. I rely on your support to continue producing this newsletter.
Thanks Brian a well crafted and informative piece of a man who but for poor decisions by previous presidents would likely have had a second term, I refer to the propping up of the shah which ultimately led to the storming of the American embassy and the demise of the carter tenure.
On a sombre note, the best known Georgian politician ATM maybe MTG,. The anti Carter
Jimmy Carter may been the most intellectually gifted man to serve as President. Add in his dedication to righting the wrongs of the past, fervent defense of democracy, and self-less life, and he maybe the most remarkable American citizen of this century touching more people than anybody. Who else would voluntarily be lowered into a melting down reactor core as he did in Canada in the 50s?
While many consider his presidency a failure, nobody else except maybe Bill Clinton made a bigger contribution to Middle East peace. But the second oil embargo, Iran, inflation, and the so-called “malaise speech” did him in for re-election. But that speech was truth, and to this day there are too many that want to ignore the truth.
But even those events that doomed his presidency were in the making long before he entered the Oval Office. Iran was created in the 50s by the CIA overthrowing the elected government. Inflation was well embedded many years before he took office, but most forget it was Carter who named Paul Volker as Chair of the Fed who took the action needed to stop inflation. And the oil embargo only exacerbated inflation.
We should be so lucky to have somebody of Jimmy Carter’s character and dedication lead this country again. But the question is, would Carter, give the nature of politics today, even come close to winning election? And if not, what does that say about us and the system we have allowed to be created today?